The Morningstar's Fate
Graymarrow seeks the Shores of Gold, clashing with the crew of the Morningstar which is captained by Eli Slate. After a long drawn-out chase, Graymarrow manages to catch the crew of the Morningstar and strands their souls using a curse in order to maroon the crew on Old Faithful Isle, making them unable to pass on to the Ferry of the Damned.
One member of the Morningstar crew did, however, manage to escape.
Tall Tale: The Fate of the Morningstar